Utpal Borpujari

May 5, 2019

Of anti-PRC protests, a film festival and a violent night in Itanagar

https://www.firstpost.com/india/of-anti-prc-protests-and-a-violent-night-in-itanagar-6244891.html Published on 12/03.2019

By Utpal Borpujari

It was with palpable excitement that I had taken the flight to Dibrugarh from New Delhi on February 21. The excitement was on two counts: that I will get to cross the Bogibeel bridge, the country’s longest rail-cum-road bridge, across the mighty Brahmaputra for the first time, and that my Assamese feature film “Ishu” will be screened at the 1st Itanagar International Film Festival to be held in the capital city of Arunachal Pradesh from the next day.

The Bogibeel bridge gives a panoramic view of the massive Brahmaputra, and we took just about 10 minutes to cross the river across the 4.94-km-long bridge, which has come as a real boon for people of both Assam and Arunachal Pradesh. In a few hours’ time, we had crossed Gogamukh, Dhemaji and Lakhimpur towns to reach Bandardewa, the town on both sides of the inter-state border.

Here we were told, after the border sentries had checked our Inner Line Permits, that we will have to wait for an escort vehicle as there was a 48-hour bandh called by several local organisations against the government’s decision to consider giving Permanent Resident Certificates (PRC) to six non-Arunachal Pradesh Scheduled Tribes (non-APST) that had migrated from Assam many decades back and settled mainly in the Namsai and Changlang districts in southern Arunachal Pradesh. These communities are Deuri, Mishing, Moran, Sonowal Kachari, Adivasi and Gorkha.

We reached Itanagar by around 9pm without any fuss, barring a road blockade by a group of youth who let us pass after some initial protest. Next morning, over breakfast at the Waii International Hotel, I met several film personalities from across the Northeast and rest of India – veteran Bollywood director-producer-actor Satish Kaushik, Shillong boy Ronnie Lahiri who has produced all of Shoojit Sircar’s directorial ventures and a few others, National Award-winning filmmakers Pradip Kurbah (Meghalaya), Lipika Singh Darai (Odisha), Meghnad and Biju Toppo (Jharkhand), Haobam Paban Kumar and Oinam Doren (both Manipur), Joseph Pulinthanath (Tripura), Manju Borah and Samujjal Kashyap (both Assam), actress Lin Laishram, musician Joi Barua and directors Sanjib Dey, Mukul Haloi and a few others.

As we got ready to proceed to the opening ceremony, we were told that it has been postponed till the evening because of the ongoing bandh. None of us had foreseen the brewing dark clouds – either during the whole day when we mostly lounged around, or in the evening when we were told that the programme has been postponed till the next day because of disturbances in the town.

It was past midnight, when everyone was ready to retire to his or her room, serious trouble started – we saw some fires erupting at a distance in the area where the Dorjee Khandu Convention Centre, the festival venue, stood. Slowly more fires erupted, and by around 1 am, the entire area surrounding the convention centre and the nearby Indira Gandhi park, was aflame. We could hear tear gas shells going off and then bullets being fired. Later, we got to know that the protestors had become violent as one of them had been injured in police firing earlier in the evening as they tried to storm the Secretariat building.

While we were safe at the hotel, nearly 100 people, mostly performers who were practising for the opening ceremony and personnel of the organizing team, were trapped in the Convention Centre. With Internet having been shut down, there was no way to find out what really was happening, and when I called up Sattriya dancer Answesa Mahanta, who was among those trapped, I could sense a real sense of fear in her voice. “The protestors have told us that they have nothing against us and won’t harm us, and has forbade us from going out from here, but everything is burning outside, and we don’t know what will happen next,” she had told me. Every vehicle parked outside the Convention Centre and at the IG park area were burnt and many musicians, including Alobo Naga of Nagaland and Suman Kalyan Dutta of Assam, lost all their equipment in the fire. Fortunately, nobody was harmed physically by the protestors.

All the five inflatable cinema halls, erected by Picture Time, were burnt down to ashes. So were the numerous food and other stalls around the venue. With the situation still tense but seemingly under control next day, arrangements were made to take all the stranded festival participants out of Itanagar to Assam border via the Itanagar-Gohpur road. Later, as we reached Dibrugarh late evening, we got information that massive violence had erupted again in Itanagar and Naharlagun again, and three people had been killed in police firing. The violence continued the next day (Monday, February 25), with the mob damaging and setting afire the private residence of Deputy Chief Minister Chowna Mein, damanged several shopping complexes, car showrooms, government offices and had looted stores. This, despite the Army having staged flag marches and curfew having been imposed.

Chief Minister Pema Khandu later tweeted and spoke at a media interaction to state that the idea of giving PRC to the six communities had been dropped. Earlier, the government intended to implement the recommendation of a Joint High-Powered Committee (JHPC) to give PRC to the six communities.

Looking from a neutral viewpoint, both sides of the PRC debate have their valid arguments. For its 83,743 sq km area, Arunachal Pradesh is very sparsely populated – it has a population of just 13.84 lakh according to the 2011 Census – with 26 major and over 100 sub-tribes making up its ethnic diversity that is an anthropologist’s delight. Many of these tribes have populations less than 50,000, some even less than 10,000. Most of them oppose the idea of giving PRC for the six non-APST communities whose total population would be not more than a few lakhs, saying such a decision would negatively impact the smaller tribes. They contend that giving PRC will lead to influx of more members of these communities from Assam, leading to threat to existence of communities like Singphos who are just around 6,000 in number.

On the other hand, the members of the non-APST communities argue that because they do not have PRC, they cannot get land pattas, deprived of government jobs, and cannot for UPSC and other competitive examinations, among others problems.

Quite clearly, it’s a complex issue concerning right to live and right to dignity on one side and right of smaller communities to exist without any ethnic pressure on the other – an issue that must be handled sensitively and carefully in the long term. In the short term, of course, the all-round violence has dented the image of otherwise peace-loving people of India’s easternmost state, an image they themselves won’t like to harbour for sure.

November 3, 2017

Cinema of the Northeast: From early Assamese films to star Manipuri directors, all you need to know

(Published on http://www.firstpost.com on 07/10/17)


By Utpal Borpujari

The positive reviews that Rima Das’ totally-independent Assamese film “Village Rockstars” received (she has directed, written , produced, photographed, edited the film, while Amrit Pritam Dutta has done the sound design and Nilotpal Bora has composed the score) at this year’s Toronto International Film Festival (TIFF) almost got overshadowed back home as the media space got captured by actor Priyanka Chopra’s misconstrued comments made on Sikkim being an ‘insurgency-hit state’ and ‘not having’ a filmmaking history till she produced the children’s film “Pahuna”, also screened at the same festival.

Thankfully, the comments by Ms Chopra got only a limited-space time in the media, as the controversy died down soon following her acknowledgement of the mistake and the subsequent apology to the Sikkim government. Thankfully, because, the spotlight needs to be on the exciting cinema that is being made by some fresh talents like Das, Haobam Paban Kumar and Pradip Kurbah in North East India rather than on ill-informed comments made by some on the geo-politically, ethnically and culturally-complex region.

What Chopra said is the not the first time that anyone has made a wrong observation on the North East, but it got more traction simply because she being a celebrity, it became saleable news. In fact, even within the media, the knowledge about the region is rarely more than perfunctory, and this writer can vouch for that having been worked in the media space in Delhi for over two decades. What made Chopra’s comments more newsy was the fact that it contrasted with her connection with the region as a Brand Ambassador for Assam Tourism and also as a producer who is looking at it seriously (after “Pahuna”, she is producing an Assamese films that will be directed by master filmmaker Jahnu Barua).

That “Pahuna” is not the first film out of Sikkim is a fact. And that gives us an opportunity here to take a look at cinemas of North East India. You may call it a primer, or a check list, but here it is, a basic guide on cinemas from what perhaps still remains India’s most less-understood region.

First, let’s find out where it all started. To be precise, the journey of cinema in what is now called North East India started in Bholaguri tea estate, located in the northern bank of the Brahmaputra, not very far from the historically-rich town of Tezpur, also called the cultural capital of Assam. Why a tea estate? The numerous histories of Indian cinema would not tell you that, because in most of them, the genesis of cinema in the region is either completely absent or is just about a footnote. The fact is that Jyotiprasad Agarwalla, an icon in Assam and the scion of a business family that had migrated from faraway Rajasthan several generations before he was born, had set up a temporary film studio in this family-owned tea estate to shoot the first Assamese film, titled “Joymoti”, which was released in 1935, initiating the film movement of Assam and also the whole region. (In a state where still “Marwaris”, as the business community with origins in Rajasthan are broadly called, are viewed as profiteers who make money at the cost of locals, the Agarwalla family is an exception and is credited with being a leading contributor to Assam’s cultural space, thanks to several poets and writers among Jyotiprasad’s predecessors).

Jyotiprasad, who collaborated with his contemporaries and giants of Assamese cultural space such as Bishnu Prasad Rabha and Phani Sarma, to make “Joymoti”, based on a play by Lakshminath Bezbarua, often considered as the father of modern Assamese literature. But it was not a whim of a man from a rich tea planter community that led Jyotiprasad to make a film. He was already an established writer, playwright, lyricist, poet, composer, in addition to being a prominent Freedom fighter (it’s perhaps not a coincidence that he gave the break to a teenager in his second and last film “Indramalati”, made some years later, who later on emerged as another cultural giant of Assam and India, and who went by the name of Bhupen Hazarika).

It was just four years ago, in 1931, that India’s first “talkie” film “Alam Ara” had been released, and films were regularly being made in Mumbai and Bengal by then, but in Assam, it was still an unknown realm. But Jyotiprasad did not want to do an amateurish job, and went to the famed UFA Studios in Germany where he learnt the basics of filmmaking, and also got impressed by the realistic approach of cinema taken by the Germans and the Soviets. So, while much of the filmmaking in rest of India was focusing on religious and mythological cinema, he picked a historical subject, about an Ahom princess Joymoti who had sacrificed her life for the sake of the Ahom-ruled Assam in the 17th century,

Being a nationalist, Jyotiprasad picked a theme that had much resonance in those days, with the anti-British sentiment building up across the country. And he used the inspiring tale of Joymoti to subtly lend a cinematic support to the Freedom Struggle. While doing it, he took a realistic approach, and eschewed the melodramatic route, thus laying the foundation of Assam’s cinema on realism. It’s another matter that it took more than four decades after that for Assamese cinema to actually strongly pick up the realistic approach to cinema.

The tragedy was that Jyotiprasad had to release his film in Raunak cinema in Calcutta (now Kolkata) because there was no cinema hall in Assam. He of course released the film later in Assam, starting with a theatre hall in Guwahati, called the Kumar Bhaskar Natya Mandir. The lack of screening space meant “Joymoti” was an unmitigated financial disaster.

After Jyotiprasad showed the way, films started getting made in Assam quite regularly, though not many in number. Quite a few of them were notable in local context, and some are now considered as films that need fresh re-evaluation for their cinematic value, such as Bhupen Hazarika’s first film “Era Bator Sur (The Song of the Deserted Path”), in which he documented must of Assam’s musical culture through a fictional story, and Sarbeswar Chakraborty’s patriotic sage “Maniram Dewan”, which has several immortal songs by Hazarika, including the stirring “Buku Hom Hom Kore”, which was later transliterated by him into “Dil Hoom Hoom Kare” in Kalpana Lajmi’s “Rudali”.

As the North East India as we know it now took shape over the years, with states of Meghalaya, Nagaland and Mizoram carved out of Assam, and Sikkim getting incorporated first into India and then made a part of the “North East” region as an administrative decision, filmmaking efforts also started gradually in other states. Manipur, which had its first film made by Deba Kumar Bose, a Bengali filmmaker from Kolkata, in 1972 – the film was “Matamgi Manipur (Today’s Manipur) – has the most well-developed film industry along with Assam in the region, with both content-driven and mainstream masala stuff being made concurrently over the years. In other states, filmmaking is a more recent phenomena, with only Meghalaya having a sporadic filmmaking journey since 1981, when the first Khasi language film “Ka Synjuk Ri ki Laiphew Syiem (The Alliance of 30 Kings)” directed by Hamlet Bareh Ngapkynta, was released.

In a region where the usage of the term “film industry” is done more for the want of a more appropriate term, the reality is that only Assam and Manipur has a regular filmmaking tradition, though video films in local languages for local consumption have been made in other states quite regularly in recent years, though their cinematically they have hardly any merit simply because of the fact that while the easy availability of digital cameras has enabled lot of young film makers from the region make interesting short films and documentaries, it has also enabled some film illiterate but glamour-struck people to make what can be described at best as poor imitations of B or C-grade films in Hindi, Bengali or Telugu films. And even in these two regular filmmaking states, Manipuri filmmakers make films for budgets in the range of Rs 10-15 lakh, while in Assam, a film with a budget of over Rs 50 lakh is still considered a big budget one. In fact, in Assam, only in recent years a couple of films have crossed the Rs 1 crore budget, and only very recently, singer-musician Zubeen Garg produced and directed “Mission China” which with its reported Rs 2 crore-plus budget, has become the highest-budgeted film of North East ever.

The major problem for filmmakers in the region is lack of enough theatres, with quite a few states not even having a permanent cinema hall, and except Assam, all other states having cinema halls having less than 10 screens each. But in addition to that, another problem is that North East India is a virtual Tower of Babel with nearly 275 ethnic communities with as many languages and dialects, most of which are not understood by communities other than that which speaks it. So, when a film is made in, say Monpa, Sherdukpen or Wancho dialects of Arunachal Pradesh (for example “Sonam” by Ahsan Mujid, “Crossing Bridges” by Sange Dorjee Thongdok and “The Head Hunter” by Nilanjan Datta respectively), their local target audience comprises small tribes of a few thousand people (in most cases less than 50,000), who are spread across difficult mountain terrain in small villages, all places which have no access to cinema halls. So, a film made in such a dialect can have no commercial prospect locally, and can hope to earn back its investment back only if the film travels outside India and is acquired by a foreign distributor. Even local distribution efforts, through “travelling” or “tent” cinema models, are not easy to achieve in the region that has a difficult geographic terrain. And, of course, outside their specific local regions, in rest of India, such films stand no chance commercially as even films made in much bigger languages hardly travel outside their respective states (though the scenario is now changing with multiplexes in major cities releasing films in various languages, though in a limited manner).

Quite clearly, films are not made in this part of the world for only commercial reasons, though there was a time when Assamese films had quite a sizeable market, glimpses of which got seen with recent stupendous Box Office success of “Mission China”, with Assamese crowds thronging the halls in such a way after over two decades, the last time being in 1995, when the gargantuan hit “Joubone Amoni Kore (My Youth Troubles Me)” had come along.

But undaunted by inter-connected problems like dearth of funding, lack of enough cinema halls and a society that has been almost always in turmoil, filmmakers in the region have continued to weave their dreams, seeking to tell stories relevant to the region and its societies, over the years, and more so in recent times. While funding for feature films are often hard to come by, talented youngsters are making a gamut of interesting short films and documentaries, picking up themes that are relevant and current. But, like everything else about the Northeast, this had remained largely outside the so-called ‘mainland’ India’s consciousness.

Over the years, the region has produced several filmmakers who have earned high praise nationally and internationally through their socially-responsible cinema. They include Jahnu Barua and the late Dr Bhabendra Nath Saikia of Assam, and Aribam Syam Sharma of Manipur, as also the multifaceted genius Dr Bhupen Hazarika. This, even as those like P C Barua, Danny Denzongpa, Seema Biswas, S D & R D Burman and Salil Choudhury have made a place in ‘mainland’ cinema of different eras, including Adil Hussain and Reema Kagti in more recent times.

Manipur is actually a great example of how one can turn in adverse situation to an advantage. After Hindi films were ‘banned’ by Revolutionary People’s Front , one of the numerous militant groups in the state, in September 2000, leading to the closure of most of the cinema halls in the Imphal Valley (the hill distrcits of Manipur did not have a single cinema hall then, and do not have even now). This led the local filmmakers to devise an economic model in which they shoot their films in the digital format in ultra low budgets and hold ticketed shows in various available halls (theatre halls, community halls, etc., though a few cinema halls in Imphal city has reopened in recent times), this recovering their investments and even making profits.

Those who follow meaningful Indian cinema would know that in Assam, both Jahnu Barua and Dr Bhabendra Nath Saikia have contributed immensely given some really good films. Barua’s “Halodhiya Choraye Baodhan Khai” (Catastrophe) that did commendable international business. There have been several other filmmakers who have made one or two acclaimed films before fading into the oblivion as despite winning both national and international honours for their initial films, they never got the funding for their next films. Among them the most notable one is being Gautam Bora (whose only film “Wosobipo” in the Karbi tribal language was screened at the Berlin Film Festival apart from winning the Indira Gandhi Award for the Best First Film of a Director in the National Film Awards), and Dr Santwana Bordoloi (whose only film till recently was “Adajya” in Assamese, which had won a jury award at the International Film Festival of India in 1996. She recently made another film titled “Maj Rati Keteki”). There have been a couple of notable exceptions though, such as Manju Borah (“Baibhav”, “Laaj”, “Aai Ko Naai”, etc., in Assamese, “Ko:Yad” in Mising, and “Dai Huduni Methai” in Bodo languages) and Sanjib Sabhapandit (“Juye Poora Xoon”, “Jatinga Ityady”, “Dikchow Banat Palaax”, etc.), who have managed to make socially-relevant films with small budgets. There have been several other serious filmmakers who have shone through their films, such as Sanjeev Hazorika (“Haladhar”, “Meemagxa”), Bidyut Chakraborty (“Raag Birag”), Ahsan Mujid (who made “Sonam”, the first film in the Monpa dialect of Arunachal Pradesh), etc. And before all of them, it was Padum Barua who in 1976 gave rebirth to Jyotiprasad’s vision of realistic cinema through his unheralded master piece “Ganga Chilanir Pakhi” in Assamese, which remained his only film.

Manipur, where Aribam Sharma gave outstanding films like “Imagi Ningthem” and “Ishanou” (screened in the Un Certain Regard section of the 1991 Cannes Film Festival), younger filmmakers are making an effort to make films to tell stories that capture the turmoil of the present-day society as well as folk tales and stories from literature. The most prominent among them, and perhaps of the most important young cinematic voice in the entire North East now, is Haobam Paban Kumar, who after a string of internationally-acclaimed documentaries, recently made his debut fiction film “Loktak Leirembee (Lady of the Lake)” which has scorched the festival circuit from Busan to Berlin.

Some remarkable young talents are emerging from states like Mizoram, from where self-taught filmmaker Mapuia Chawnghtu made the highly-stylised “Khawnlung Run”, or “The Raid of Khawnlung”, with a miniscule budget of only Rs 12 lakh, and Arunachal Pradesh, from where a young Sange Dorje Thongdok made “Crossing Bridges”, the first feature film in the Sherdukpen dialect, which was acquired by Insomnia Films of France), In Meghalaya, Pradip Kurbah made the dramatic Khasi language film “Ri”, which sought to create a debate around the sense of alienation among the youth of the region and how some of them get sucked into a world of violence, and followed it up with the much-appreciated drama “Onataah”, whose Hindi, Marathi and Malayalam remake rights have been sold, a feat for North Eastern cinema that has only once been achieved earlier by Abdul Majid’s Assamese film “Chameli Memsaab” that was remade in Bengali and Hindi. In Sikkim, the smallest of the North Eastern states, several young filmmakers have emerged, such as Karma Takapa whose “Ralang Road” got its world premiere at this year’s Karlovy Vary, and Prashant Rasaily, whose “Acharya” and “Katha” got good reviews in several festivals. In Tripura, Joseph Pulinthanath, a Keralite priest settled in the state, has made a couple of acclaimed films in the tribal Kokborok language, most notably “Yarwng”.

A few films from the North East have got limited release outside the region, such as Jahnu Barua’s “Baandhon”, Rajni Basumatary’s “Raag” and Kenny Basumatary’s laugh riot of a martial arts comedy “Local Kung Fu” (all Assamese), via the now-defunct PVR Director’s Rare initiative. The 2nd installment of “Local Kung Fu” got a commercial release in a few metro cities earlier this year, while Zubeen Garg’s “Mission China” also got a good few days’ run in the metros, thanks to the increasing Assamese population in Delhi, Mumbai, Bangalore and Pune. With the emergence of popular video-on-demand platforms like Netflix and Amazon Prime, which are picking up good content for a global audience, a window of opportunity sure exists for the filmmakers from the region who want to tell their own stories. Bhaskar Hazarika’s Assamese film “Kothanodi (The River of Fables)” sometime back became the first North Eastern film to be picked up by Netflix and is said to be having a decent run on the platform. Still, filmmaking in the North East remains more of a passion project than a commercial venture. But then, only passion can lead to the birth of a film like “Village Rockstars”.

Next Page »

Blog at WordPress.com.