Utpal Borpujari

April 5, 2010

Book Review: 50 Indian Film Classics

By Utpal Borpujari

Top 100 or Top 50 lists in any subject always elicits keen interest in the media as well as people. Such lists not only give a peek into the thought process of their creators but also provide a ready reckoner on many things. But such ‘Top’ lists also provide the basis for arguments, as each such list is the creation of a single mind that has a particular view of things, and thus always remains debatable.

Film scholar M K Raghavendra avoids any such immediate cause for debate by intelligently calling his book 50 Indian Film Classics. Going for this title, he has ensured that nobody can argue with him why he did not include a certain film in the list, as nobody can argue that the 50 films listed in the book are not classics – either in the artistic term or in the mainstream term.

Raghavendra is known for his strong and unique points of view. His earlier book “Seduced by the Familiar: Narration and Meaning in Indian Popular Cinema” provided an alternative and much-refreshing debate about what mainstream cinema is all about. One may or may not agree with Raghavendra’s academically-inclined theses, but they always provide interesting reading and the much-needed fresh air in the mostly-stale air of Indian film criticism.

This book too is another example of the author’s interesting analysis of cinema, in this case, of Indian cinema. He has chosen to encompass a huge period of 81 years, from 1925 to 2006, in his book, dissecting some of the most debated movies of their times. Setting out to pluck 50 best films, even if they are one’s own personal choice, from such a time span is no mean task. But Raghavendra takes the plunge courageously, though he admits that it is no mean task to evaluate cinema as disparate as “Pather Panchali” and “Amar Akbar Anthony” though both happen to be landmark films in their own ways.

The author’s selection is eclectic, to say the least. On the one hand, the films critiqued by him include art house classics like “Parasakthi” (Tamil, 1952), “Pather Panchali” (Bengali, 1957), “Samskara” (Kannada, 1970), “Imagi Ningthem” (Manipuri, 1981) and “Mukhamukham” (Malayalam, 1984), and on the other, they comprise mainstream mega-successes like “Lagaan” (2001), “Kabhi Alvida Naa Kehna” (2006), “Sholay” (1975), “Deewar” (1975) and “Satya” (1998). But for each of the films selected, he tries to bring in a unique interpretation from the societal point of view.

For example, in case of “Kabhi Alvida Naa Kehna”, he argues that the space in the narrative has been deliberately “emptied” of the Indian nation and tradition – by setting it in the USA and by “playing down” of the symbols representing tradition – to render it suitable for adultery. In the case of Govind Nihalani’s “Aakrosh”, he finds fault in representation of the tribals who are “singularly disabled” and need to be rescued by a middle-class person in the form of the lawyer. For every film he has chosen to pick up, Raghavendra has likewise offered interesting interpretations, making it an interesting journey through film history.

This is an interesting read, though surely, there can be arguments about why he left out so many other films that are much interesting “classics” than quite a few included in the book. But then again, that is a matter of opinion, and one should read this book as one such set of opinions.

(50 Indian Film Classics; by M K Raghavendra; Collins; pp 323; Rs 350)

(Published in Deccan Herald, www.deccanherald.com, www.deccanheraldepaper.com, 04-04-2010)



Leave a Comment »

No comments yet.

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.

%d bloggers like this: